I tried on coats at Gap, Banana Republic, and Old Navy. The experience reminded me that a great piece is worth investing in.

I started my search for a stylish and well-constructed peacoat at Gap.

When I walked in, I appreciated that the store was easy to navigate and neatly organized. Plus, I found the coat I was looking for almost immediately.

I tried on the wool-blend wrap coat and could tell right away that it offered a nice shape and structured fit that would fit easily over layers.

I liked the thick-notch lapels, and thought the material (52% recycled wool, 40% recycled polyester, 8% other) felt warm without being overly bulky. However, the wool blend felt a bit itchy, especially around the neck area where it directly touched my skin.

Plus, there were no buttons and the pockets were hidden, making it look somewhat like a bathrobe.

Although it was a good, basic option, I wanted something with a little more flair. I also had a hard time justifying the price of $248 for a coat that was 40% polyester.

After striking out at Gap, I decided to try Banana Republic for another option. The store was neatly organized, and I was able to locate a black peacoat easily.

When I saw the $550 price tag on the Italian-wool cashmere wrap coat, I thought, “There is absolutely no way I would pay that much for a coat.” But after trying it on, I reconsidered.

I could immediately tell that the quality of the material (made with 91% wool, 6% cashmere, and 3% other materials) was thick and warm, with no polyester in sight. The inside lining was also silky and smooth, and the overall fabric felt soft and comfortable without itching.

I also loved the overall design of this coat. The pointed collar and large pockets added chic touches that were flattering yet functional.

This try-on reminded me that it’s important to invest in pieces that will actually last a long time. I know this coat is something I would wear every winter for years.

I’m a big fan of Old Navy because it offers both basic and trending styles for an approachable price.

However, my local Old Navy was less organized than the other stores I visited, so it took me a bit longer to find a black peacoat. Thankfully, I was able to find one and brought it to the fitting room.

The first thing I noticed when trying on the oversized twill overcoat is that it didn’t have a waist tie, which, to me, feels like a must for adding shape and style to any peacoat.

The coat was also made of 100% recycled polyester, so I’m not sure how warm it would actually keep me during winter. The fabric also felt less flexible than the others I tried on, leaving less room for layers underneath.

I did like the overall style, though — it had a spread lapel and the buttons featured an eye-catching texture.

This was my least favorite coat out of the three, but for $90, I think it’s a solid option for anyone shopping on a budget.

Overall, the Banana Republic coat impressed me most, thanks to its durable fabric blend, comfortable fit, and elegant design.

This shopping day reminded me that high-quality staple pieces are worth investing in.